Williams Lake Homes and Neighbourhoods:
Today and Tomorrow
Report on Results of a Study to Discover
Current Housing and Neighbourhood Characteristics,
Needs for the Future, Citizens' Preferences, and
What Governments, Home Builders and Community Groups
Can Do to Meet the Needs and Preferences
by
Stuart Adams & Associates
Under guidance of the Williams Lake Housing Committee
for the
Social Planning Advisory Network
and City of Williams Lake
1997
** Please note that, unless otherwise noted, any views expressed
in this report are those of the consultants and not necessarily
those of the sponsoring agencies.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Study Findings
Trends
- The population of Greater Williams Lake is projected to increase
by 14.2 percent over the next 10 years and 23.9 percent over
the next 25 years. The number of households (each needing its
own residence) will increase even more: by 25.2 percent over
the next 10 years and by 44.7 percent over the next 25 years.
The characteristics of households will change. They will be smaller
and more of them will consist of single parent families, middle-aged
adults without children at home, and seniors.
- In the 1990s, the real incomes of many households have been
declining, stagnating or increasing very slowly. There is little
reason for hope that these trends will reverse in the foreseeable
future.
- At the same time, Williams Lake housing prices have been
rising steeply, primarily due to rising land prices. In addition,
there has been a rental housing shortage. As a result, housing
that is both suitable and affordable has been getting beyond
the reach of increasing numbers of households.
Implications
- The population, income and housing trends have profound implications
for what will be needed in the way of new housing. There will
be more need for apartments, row houses, manufactured homes,
smaller houses on small lots and housing designed especially
for seniors. In addition, there will be more need for non-traditional
housing, such as small "granny houses" sharing lots
with larger single family detached houses and "flex homes"
that can be adapted to the changing needs of owners and tenants.
Responses
- In the 1990s, the Williams Lake housing market has been responding
to changing needs by supplying types of housing (e.g., row houses
and manufactured homes) that are more affordable, both because
they use less land and because they cost less to build.
- Currently, the Social Planning Advisory Network and City
are responding by spearheading efforts (through the Williams
Lake Housing Committee) to understand the housing situation in
Greater Williams Lake, to identify opportunities for improving
the situation, and to take appropriate action.
- Meanwhile, the federal government has withdrawn from its
long-standing commitment to non-profit housing and the provincial
government's commitment has been insufficient.
Needs
- The Williams Lake Housing Committee has identified immediate
need for a substantial number of units of non-profit housing
for students, Urban Natives, people with mental challenges, lone
parent families, and seniors. In the longer term, the most pressing
need will be for seniors housing of all types, including housing
for independent living and housing for seniors needing various
levels of care.
- The current City of Williams Lake Official Community Plan
and Zoning Bylaw and a recently approved Neighborhood Plan indicate
that, until recently, there has been a re-active rather than
pro-active response to emerging population, income and housing
realities. Information arising from this study points to a need
for new policies that address the emerging realities.
Residents' concerns
- Most of the residents of Williams Lake are well aware of
the emerging population, income and housing realities. Many see
their own needs and preferences changing and are not just ready
to accept but ready to encourage change. Most, however, have
legitimate concerns about protecting their own homes and neighbourhoods
from harm.
- Residents' responses to the study questionnaire indicate
that homes and neighbourhoods are so connected that they cannot
speak about the qualities of one without speaking about the qualities
of the other. They have many concerns about both and they would
like to see these concerns addressed by their local governments.
Other factors
Other factors to be considered in making housing choices for
the future include:
- The prosperity of Williams Lake depends on what it does to
ensure that it has a stock of good quality, affordable housing
since the availability of such housing is one of the most important
considerations in the decisions of businesses and industries
to choose a particular location.
- The retirement industry is a major and growing industry in
North America, an industry that could be attracted to Williams
Lake. It tends to concentrate in communities that offer a variety
of good quality housing options and much in way of community
attractiveness and amenity.
The "new urbanism" approach
- Good home, neighbourhood and community design is essential
for any community that aspires to be the best it can be. If Williams
Lake wishes to create and achieve a new vision for its future,
it would do well to learn more about "the new urbanism"
and to consider incorporating some of its concepts into the vision.
The new urbanism is largely a rediscovery of the better design
ideas from older cities, including convenient and attractive
pedestrian ways so people are encouraged to walk, and a higher
density of development with a greater variety of housing types
mixed together in the same neighbourhoods.
- The more compact development encouraged by the new urbanism
helps to conserve land and energy.
- It also makes good sense from a municipal finance point of
view, since lower density development (in the form of subdivisions
with standard or large lots occupied by standard or large single
family detached houses) is extremely expensive for a municipality
to service and does not pay for itself in property taxes.
Opportunities for the future
- There are excellent opportunities for SPAN, the City and
the Regional District to work together and form partnerships
with others in efforts to ensure that the people of Williams
Lake have the homes and neighbourhoods they need and prefer in
the years ahead. The following summary of recommendations points
to some of these opportunities.
Recommendations
- That SPAN, the City and the Cariboo Regional District join
in efforts to establish a housing society.
- That, pending establishment of the housing society, SPAN
and the City and Regional District support the Williams Lake
Housing Committee in its efforts to proceed with a housing project
suited to low income households. These households will include
lone parents and couples with children, couples without children
and unattached singles, with special regard for households with
students attending University College of the Cariboo.
- That SPAN, the City and the Regional District join in efforts
to establish an affordable residential land trust.
- That SPAN, the City and the Regional District make a joint
submission to the B.C. Ministry of Municipal Affairs and Housing
and CMHC asking them to organize and offering to host a conference
on federal and provincial housing policies and programs as they
apply to mid-sized and smaller B.C. communities.
- That the City of Williams Lake adopt and implement a strategy
for becoming a model twenty-first century community, one that
meets the housing and neighbourhood needs and preferences of
all of its citizens and takes optimum advantage of new information
and ideas about how to design good homes and neighbourhoods.
- That, as part of the above, the City review the Westside
Neighbourhood Plan with a view to revising it.
- That the Cariboo Regional District co-operate in the above
efforts, in recognition of the fact that people living in areas
surrounding the City but outside of its official boundaries are
part of the community generally known as Williams Lake.
- That, as interim measures, the City and Regional District
develop statements of housing policy. (An example is provided
in the expanded description of this recommendation in Part Seven.)
- That the City establish an Illegal Suites Task Force and
invite the B.C. Ministry of Housing, SPAN and its member agencies
(including First Nations and the Cariboo Friendship Society)
to join in reviewing the conditions of illegal suites and identifying
appropriate ways of improving those conditions, while attempting
to ensure no loss in the City's severely limited stock of affordable
housing units.
- That the City and the Regional District propose to the Manufactured
Homes Association of B.C. that the Association sponsor a study
and demonstration project
a) to identify concerns about the designs of manufactured
homes and manufactured home parks, and
b)
to identify and demonstrate design solutions
and that, as part of their proposal, the City and Regional
District offer assistance in finding a potential site in the
Williams Lake area suitable for a model manufactured home development
to demonstrate the design solutions